OKAY SO THIS WAS LONG OVERDUE. But I figured now is the time to do this.
At first I was going to use Max Irons as Edward since the Bella in question is dating him at the moment, but then I remembered the first and foremost Edward of the book fans, and the first and foremost Edward of OGAEC.
Presenting - the Twilight Dream Team, Gaspard Ulliel and Emily Browning!
Original Photo of Gaspard
Original Photo of Emily
Out of all these Edwards, who's your favorite?

Anonymous
I know this sounds strange and not what you do. But, could you do my husband as Edward? Lol.
Absolutely, just submit a photo, keep checking back, and we’ll make it happen!
(Anybody else who would like that special someone to become the lion to their lamb (or just want to see their reactions and get a good laugh), submit your photos! Let’s see how well they’ll look like as Edward Cullen!)
Personally I'm not big on the whole franchise of Twilight, but your Photoshop editing is mind-blowing. I'm impressed!

Anonymous
Zac Efron as Edward Cullen
Dear followers: we thank you. We care about you. We pay attention to all your feedback - the comments, the praise, the fangirling, the flames, the rage, the WTFOMGWHYs. (Sincere apologies to those RDJ and Leo DiCaprio fans who felt the need to tell us they wanted to kill themselves after they saw those shops. I mean there’s better things to die for but I suppose a photo edit is pretty traumatizing.)
This is for that one person in particular who made us remember that we had to do this one, as well as all the Twilight fans who would give people the evil eye when they suggested the High School Musical heartthrob be Edward Cullen. Hey, it only seems fitting to imagine what would have happened if he had taken the role.
Original Photo
Leonardo DiCaprio as Edward Cullen
A noticeable actor who has a large portfolio for male leads from Romeo + Juliet and The Man in the Iron Mask to Catch Me If You Can and Inception, Leo was and is still known for being the affection of many women young and old. As requested, here is the Titanic heartthrob back in his younger days as the modern day fangirl attraction.
Original Photo
how about Leonardo DiCaprio when he was a teen? :)
Henry Cavill as Edward Cullen
Stephenie Meyer’s dream Edward Cullen, the Tudors star who will also be Superman in the upcoming Man of Steel is today’s Topless Tuesday Edward Cullen. However, Rob was chosen over Henry because of Henry’s age. Ironically, several fans wanted him to be Cedric Diggory when Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire was to be produced - but we all know how that went too.
Original Photo